How to Communicate with a High-Conflict Spouse

Are You Ready for Divorce?

TAKE THIS QUIZ and Find Out. 

Minute Read

Episode Description 

If every conversation with your spouse turns into a battle you can’t win, you’re not imagining it, and you’re not alone. High-conflict personalities follow predictable patterns, and Bill Eddy, the Co-founder of the High Conflict Institute and a former therapist, family lawyer, and mediator, has spent decades studying exactly how high-conflict personalities work. He’s also written the book on how to communicate effectively with a high-conflict spouse. 

In this podcast episode, Bill explains how to recognize a high-conflict person (even without a diagnosis!) and how to spot the patterns that keep pulling you into the same arguments. Bill also reveals why the moves most people instinctively make when dealing with a high-conflict person often backfire.

You’ll learn the four common mistakes that almost always escalate things, plus a simple one-word swap that can change the tone of a tense negotiation. 

Bill also covers when to keep trying to settle and when to stop, why the most aggressive lawyer isn’t necessarily your best choice, and how to present your case so a judge pays attention to what matters most … even when your spouse is “charming.”

Bill also reveals what you can quietly do before you announce your divorce that will prepare you for what’s coming, how to tell ordinary conflict apart from coercive control, and why safety always has to come first. 

If you are dreading divorce because you’re married to a high-conflict spouse, this podcast episode is for you.

Show Notes

About Bill

Bill Eddy, LCSW, Esq., is the co-founder and Director of Innovation for the High Conflict Institute. He pioneered High Conflict Personality Theory (HCP) and is a renowned expert on managing disputes involving high-conflict personalities. With a diverse career spanning decades, Bill worked as a licensed clinical social worker and child and family therapist for 12 years, practiced as a Certified Family Law Specialist representing clients in family court for 15 years, and served as Senior Family Mediator at the National Conflict Resolution Center for 15 years.

Connect with Bill

You can connect with Bill on Facebook at High Conflict Institute. You can follow Bill on YouTube at @highconflictinstitute3717, on Instagram at highconflictinstitute, and listen to his podcast, It's All Your Fault. To learn more about his work, training, and resources, visit his website at High Conflict Institute.

Key Takeaways From This Episode with Bill Eddy

  • You don't need a diagnosis to spot a high-conflict personality. Look for four patterns: blaming others 100% of the time, all-or-nothing thinking, unmanaged emotions that drive decisions, and extreme behavior that 90% of people would never engage in (like hiding money or spreading false rumors online).
  • Avoid the four moves that make things worse. Don't try to give a high-conflict person insight into their behavior, don't open up emotions, don't argue about the past, and never tell them they're high-conflict. Instead, keep the focus on choices and the future. A simple swap helps: ask "What do you think about this proposal?" rather than "How do you feel about it?"
  • Try to settle, but don't exhaust yourself. Bill recommends a two-track approach: give negotiation or mediation a real effort (about two sessions), and if there's no progress, go to court. Did you know research shows aggressive and assertive attorneys get equally good outcomes? Look for the lawyer judges respect, not the one with the scariest reputation.
  • In court, simple and repetitive beats a long story. Choose three short themes for your biggest concerns (like "undermining mother's parenting" or "false statements to the court"), back each with your worst examples and real evidence, and get it all into the first two or three pages, before the judge's attention drifts.
  • Prepare quietly before you announce the divorce. Consult a lawyer, find a therapist who understands your spouse's personality, keep same-day notes of any troubling incidents somewhere safe, and write every message in BIFF format: brief, informative, friendly, and firm. Skip apologies and admonishments, and practice writing BIFF responses yourself rather than leaning on AI, so you learn to think more strategically.
  • Know the signs of coercive control, and leave safely. An ongoing sense of fear and dread, and changing your routines to avoid upsetting your partner, set coercive control apart from situational conflict. Because leaving can be the most dangerous time, get yourself and your kids to a safe place first and let your lawyer serve the papers with a calm cover letter. There is real hope: with consistent boundaries, the conflict tends to fade over time.
  • Do you like what you've heard? 

    Share the love so more people can benefit from this episode too!

    Transcript

    How to Communicate with a High-Conflict Spouse

    SPEAKERS

    Karen Covy,  Bill Eddy

    TRANSCRIPT

    Karen: Hello, and welcome to Off the Fence, a podcast where we deconstruct difficult decision-making to try to figure out what keeps us stuck, and more importantly, how do we get unstuck? I'm your host, Karen Covy, a former divorce lawyer, mediator, and arbitrator turned coach, author, and entrepreneur.

    With me today, I have a very special guest. I am so excited, I can barely contain myself. My guest is the infamous Bill Eddy, the one and only. Bill is the co-founder and director of innovation for the High Conflict Institute. He pioneered the High Conflict Personality theory, and has become an expert on managing disputes involving people with high-conflict personalities, especially bullies. He was a licensed clinical social worker therapist, working with children and families for over 12 years, then a certified family law specialist lawyer representing clients in family court for 15 years, and then he became the senior family mediator at the National Conflict Resolution Center for 15 years. Bill has literally written the book on high-conflict personalities. As a matter of fact, he's written several. Here are just two, and we will link to all of his books in the show notes.

    Bill, thank you so much for being here. I am thrilled to have you.

    Bill: Thank you so much, Karen. It's great to be with you and to see you again.

    Karen: Thank you. We were talking before we started about sort of how these concepts have evolved over time, and you've been in on this from the very beginning. But let's start, for people who might not be familiar with the technical definition: what is a high-conflict personality?

    Bill: Well, first of all, it's not a diagnosis, it's a description of conflict behavior. And so we've narrowed it down, really, to four key things. A preoccupation with blaming others, and by saying that, it's 100% other people's fault, is what they say, and they take 0%. So if you've ever been their target of blame, you're getting that 100% blame. "It's all your fault," is what they say over and over and over again. People will probably recognize this.

    The second is a lot of all-or-nothing thinking in many ways, not just "it's all your fault and not mine," but also finding solutions, like, what should we do this coming weekend? The schedule needs to change a little bit, and high-conflict people say, "It's my way or the highway. You've got to do it my way." There isn't "let's look at alternatives."

    The third is unmanaged emotions. So you often get escalated emotions, sudden intense anger, bursting into tears, just jumping up and running out of a room when you're having a discussion. So emotions take over and drive a lot of their decision-making. Now, you don't always see this, so some people are very calm, collected, reasonable, but what's driving them is an effort to punish the other person for splitting up with them, or to hold on to the other person because they don't want to lose them. So, emotions drive their decision-making.

    And the fourth is extreme behavior: they may do something that 90% of people would never do, like spreading knowingly false rumors on the internet to harm somebody's reputation. Hiding money, of course, in divorce. You know all about that. Hiding children in divorce. Domestic violence. So all of these things that really kind of catch you by surprise, that stand out. There's a pattern of behavior supporting those behaviors, so that's something we see with some high-conflict people. So those four characteristics are how I define a high-conflict person.

    Karen: In today's world, anybody in the business hears from people they're divorcing a narcissist, whether that person is actually diagnosed or not, right? So how does that narcissistic person or personality disorder, because they're different, how does that fit in with a high-conflict personality?

    Bill: Well, what we see is there's five personality disorders who are prone to having high-conflict personalities, but they don't all necessarily have them. So, just briefly: narcissistic personality disorder, borderline personality disorder, histrionic personality disorder, antisocial personality disorder, and paranoid personality disorder. Many of them have high-conflict personalities, but some don't.

    So let's take narcissists in particular. What most people think of with narcissists is they're self-centered, they don't pay attention to you, they want you to pay attention to them, they suck the oxygen out of a room of a group of people, all of that "me, me, me" stuff. But the personality disorder involves high-conflict behavior, because they have a lack of empathy. There's a meanness, even cruelty, that they may display in an effort to prove they're superior to you. And so, this is the part that's a high-conflict personality. I must say, I personally know some people with narcissistic traits who are not high-conflict people, but they're "me, me, me, me, me" people.

    So that would be the difference. If they're preoccupied with blaming others, engaging in extreme behaviors, like a personality disorder, you may also be looking at a high-conflict personality.

    Karen: How important is it to identify what kind of a person you're dealing with? If you're going through a divorce and you know that your marriage has been high conflict, you assume your divorce is going to be high conflict. Does it matter if you're dealing with a narcissist, or someone with borderline personality disorder, or some other personality disorder? Do you have to diagnose it, and does it make a difference?

    Bill: You don't need to diagnose it, but if you have a hunch, you think maybe, then there's four things I want to tell you to tell people not to do, and four things to emphasize. So let's take my presumption, which is 10% of people seem to have a high-conflict personality, and the research shows 10% of people have a personality disorder. That's been researched pretty well. About half of people with a personality disorder have a high-conflict personality. The others seem to have maybe some traits of that, but maybe more flexible. So let's say that's 10% of adults. And this may be around the world, because personality disorders are around the world.

    Let's say that divorce and other legal disputes, it's a double. In other words, they are attracted to conflict and often involved in the legal system. So I believe, and there's a lot of other people, judges, lawyers, will say about 20% of divorces are high conflict. So, the other 80%, there's things you can do that you don't have to worry about, but the 20%, there's four things to avoid, and you can avoid these with anybody. You don't have to diagnose somebody.

    First is, don't try to give the person insight into their own behavior. It doesn't work with high-conflict people. You say, "Hey buddy, can't you see you're the problem here? Can't you see this is your problem? You're creating these difficulties. You're making it hard on your son and your daughter. Can't you see? Just look at yourself in the mirror." Well, what you get back is anger, because, "If you're gonna criticize me, which has happened all my life as a high-conflict person, then I'm gonna fight back, and it's gonna be all your fault, buddy. And I'm gonna punish you for the next month, maybe the next year, for having said that I have a problem. You need to look in the mirror, not me."

    So, you get that kind of reaction. So instead, skip trying to give the person insight into themselves, and instead focus on their choices. Say, "Let's look at your choices now," or "Let's look at our choices now." So you focus them out of themselves, not into themselves, because that triggers this intense defensiveness. And like I said, you can do this with them. You don't have to give anybody feedback about their own behavior, but with 80% of people, sometimes it's a productive discussion.

    The second thing is, don't focus on emotions, and don't have an emotional confrontation. And this is surprising, and few people know this, so you and your listeners will be some of the first to know this. And that is, high-conflict people don't go through the normal grieving and healing process. The five stages: denial, anger, bargaining, depression, and then acceptance. And I might say, people with personality disorders also don't go through these. That's part of why they're stuck in a narrow range of behavior. But high-conflict people, guess where they get stuck? Anger.

    Karen: Anger.

    Bill: So, if something goes wrong, maybe they start to feel sad, it's a split second, and they're angry. And so, if you focus on emotions, and open up emotions, and say, "Well, how do you feel about that?" then what you get is they're overwhelmed with their emotions, and so you usually get an escalation of behavior. And they'll blast you back, say, "Oh, how I feel is that you're the problem." Or, "I feel that he or she is the problem, and this is terrible, what's happening, and I can't stand it." And so you have to change what you're doing. This is terrible. So, if you open up emotions, you usually drown in the conflict.

    And I know that doing mediation, if I'll say, "How do you feel about that proposal?" the person will say, "I feel terrible about that. I can't believe that she even proposed that, or he even proposed that." So, opening up emotions drowns people and undermines your chance to make progress. So, don't try to give them insight into themselves, and don't try to open up emotions, or be emotional, have an emotional confrontation with them. It's not gonna help. It's not gonna work.

    Karen: Can I interrupt just a second? So instead of asking them, "How do you feel about this proposal?" what should you ask? "What do you think about this proposal?"

    Bill: Exactly. "What do you think about this proposal? Is there something that you could do?" Because they may feel terrible about it, but, "Yeah, I could probably do that." Yeah, I forgot to say that part, what to do instead.

    Karen: No, I've got it, and I interrupted you. You were telling us what to do and what not to do.

    Bill: Yeah. So, don't try to give them insight into themselves. Don't open up emotions. The third is don't get stuck in the past. Don't argue about the past with them. It's a losing argument. And the reason they're stuck in the past is because they don't go through the grieving and healing process, but they're trying to. And so, they're saying, "Well, I was right to do what I did. You were wrong to do what you did." And they're trying to rewrite history so they don't have a loss, because they don't have a mechanism for processing the loss. And I really think it's a brain thing, and someday the brain scientists will figure out how to help people connect with that grieving and healing process, because that's where high-conflict people get stuck. They fight instead of moving forward.

    Karen: Fascinating.

    Bill: Yeah, so that's the third. So don't try to give them insight, don't open up emotions, don't get stuck in the past. Focus on the future. It's like, "Okay, well, we'll just have to agree to disagree. What I suggest that we do now…" or "Let's look at what our options are now." So you want to be future-focused. And the last one that's real easy is don't tell them they have a high-conflict personality.

    Karen: That doesn't go well?

    Bill: Never goes well. People are usually like, "It's you. You're the high-conflict person, and I will punish you for the next two or three years for having said that." So, don't go there. Everything I teach, I've learned doing it the wrong way.

    Karen: It sounds like their reactions, too, are out of proportion to the slight or insult that they received.

    Bill: Exactly, and that's a lot of that all-or-nothing thinking, and I think it's wrapped up with the emotions and inability to cope with things not going well. There's this whole reservoir of unresolved stuff that just jumps right in. And you'll see, very common with high-conflict people, they'll be discussing one issue, and they'll bring these other things: "Well, what about that, and that? And you always, and you never…" And next thing you know, there's so many issues that it's impossible to resolve them. So you don't want to get stuck there. You want to say, "Hang on, we're talking about Friday pickup at 5 o'clock. We're not talking about the last 10 years of who took the kids to karate, and whose car needs repairs, and all that stuff."

    Karen: Okay, so what about this as a strategy? You're trying to have a conversation with your high-conflict spouse. They're going crazy over all the past. Does it help if you just say, "You know what, you're right, I did all of that, you're 100% right, now let's move on"? Is that a good idea or a bad idea?

    Bill: I think it's a bad idea, because it reinforces their distortions, because they do distort things. They tend towards that all-or-nothing thinking. And so I say, "Oh, alright, I did all those things." Now, if you did all those things, then maybe you could say that, because it's accurate, but usually it's not accurate, it's an exaggeration. So, I would just say, "We're never going to agree on the past, so let's talk about what to do now."

    And that's a lot of what I tell people in mediation. I start my mediation, and I say, "Just so you know, I can't mediate the past. I understand you come in with different perspectives, and that's fine with me. My goal is to help you find agreement for the future." So it's really very future-oriented, and I encourage couples to be future-oriented. It cuts out a lot of arguments that don't go anywhere, especially with high-conflict people.

    Karen: That makes sense, but you bring up a really interesting point. There's a lot of discussion among divorce professionals about whether you can or should mediate with a high-conflict person. I know that high-conflict people thrive in a courtroom because of all the conflict and drama, but should you try to keep them out? Are they going to ever mediate actively and in good faith?

    Bill: I think it's possible and should be tried. What I tell clients is… and my clients now are consultation clients, because I'm not mediating, not representing in court, not doing therapy. Purely consultation to give people tips for strategy for their case and strategies for their lawyer. So what I say is, have a two-track approach with a high-conflict person. Try to settle your case out of court. Give it a good effort: negotiations, mediations, collaborative divorce. But don't exhaust yourself with those efforts. If you're not making any progress, I suggest have two mediation sessions, and if there's no progress after that, go to court. Because often, what happens is the high-conflict person wants the world in the divorce, and they're not going to get the world in court, and they sometimes knowingly try to bully the other person into accepting something that a judge wouldn't require.

    And so, that's why I say, of course, consult with a lawyer, or have a lawyer represent you, so you know what's realistic and what's not, because there's a lot of nuances to each of these: parenting, child support, property, etc. But don't feel pressured to settle. If it's not reasonable for you in mediation after a couple sessions, go to court, and there's a good chance you'll get a more reasonable deal than a high-conflict person is demanding.

    Karen: But what about… I've recently had a lot of clients, I don't know, this seems to be in the air these days, that are dealing with a high-conflict spouse in litigation, and that person hires the most aggressive lawyer on the planet, and they present really well, and they look very charming, and together, and all of a sudden, the person who is reasonable looks like they're the problem, and they start to lose. What can that person do to turn the tables and expose the high-conflict person for the truth of what they really are?

    Bill: Well, here's the first thing, and that is, they need to get my book, Splitting: Protecting Yourself While Divorcing Someone with Borderline or Narcissistic Personality Disorder. And whether they have that or not, this book will help you in family court with a high-conflict co-parent or ex. In there, I talk a lot about court, about what types of attorneys to look for. And there are the cutthroat attorneys, let's call them, that you mentioned. But what's interesting is the research shows that an aggressive attorney and an assertive attorney, which is presenting information and doing a good job with that, have equal good outcomes. So you yourself should not try to get the most aggressive attorney. You want to get the most respected attorney, or someone that's known as a professional, that the judges respect, and will be assertive for you, will stand up for you, but aren't going to look like they're trying to destroy the other party, which is what some, unfortunately, some lawyers try to do. You said the most aggressive in the world, or the universe, and I would say in the county, because each county has one of these most aggressive lawyers.

    And yet, you can fight back against them. So let me give you my strategy, which is in Chapter 14 of the Splitting book. That is, understand how high-conflict people communicate emotionally. And unfortunately, their emotions can hook the judge, can hook a mediator, even hook a lawyer, because emotions grab… in many ways, they grab our right hemisphere of our brain, which shortcuts the left brain logical processing. So, because they communicate emotionally, they communicate with simplicity, emotion, and repetition, and false statements, usually. The counter to that is keep it simple. Come up with three themes that describe your biggest concerns.

    So, let's say, whether you're representing a man or a woman, "undermining mother's parenting." That's a short phrase, and you repeat that a lot. "Your Honor, here's another example of undermining mother's parenting." It could be undermining father's parenting. I have just as many cases of that. "Making false statements to the court." That's common, but if the court isn't alerted to that possibility, they're not looking for that.

    Karen: Okay, let me interrupt you here, though, because so many times the false statements turn into a he said, she said. How do you convince the judge that what you're saying is actually true?

    Bill: What you need to do is have some supporting evidence, like transcripts from prior hearings. That's one of the biggest sources of false statements, is say, "This is what he said at the last hearing, and here's what the doctor's note says." So you need to have evidence that backs you up. You can't just say this, but you should say this if that's a common problem, and give your most extreme examples. If you're submitting a document to court, and in California it's a declaration, in other places it's an affidavit, you want to say, "Here's my three biggest concerns, and here's examples of why I'm asking for what I'm asking for." And under each of those three themes, which are short phrases that include some emotion but aren't too extreme, like "false," like "undermining," like "disregarding medical advice," those kinds of things, then you give the worst examples.

    One of the biggest mistakes I think family lawyers make in high-conflict cases is they give a narrative of what's happening in the case. "And the couple got together here, and then they did this, and then they did this," and on page 7 there's this terrible incident of violence, or lying, or manipulation. And right around page 7 is when the judge is starting to think about what they're gonna have for lunch. And so you miss it. So you gotta get that stuff in in the first two or three pages. "Here's my three biggest concerns, and here's the three worst examples of each of these." So by the time you're at page 3, maybe page 4, the judge gets a sense of where the case lands.

    And I do a lot of speaking to judges nowadays. And of course, they're tearing their hair out about high-conflict cases, but they tend to have what some people might consider a mailbox approach: which box does this go into? "Oh, okay, this is a domestic violence case, I'm putting it here." "Oh, this is a soccer case. Which community is the boy gonna play soccer in?" Well, I've had cases that the judge thought was a soccer case, but it was really a domestic violence case. And so you've got to get that across right away, in the first two, three, four pages, or in the first couple minutes of the lawyer's presentation, or someone self-representing, in their presentation.

    So, it's learning to be simple, repetitive, mildly emotional words, but don't act emotional. You want to act reasonable. But the mildly emotional words get the court's attention: "false statements," "undermining," "disregarding." Those kinds of words get their attention, and there's a better chance things will stick.

    Karen: So, let's talk about the couple where one person is high conflict, and the other person is afraid to even initiate the divorce because he or she knows this is not going to be easy, it's not going to be fun. What can that person do to best prepare themselves so that things can go as well as they can possibly go?

    Bill: Yeah, so what's interesting is that's the first third of the book Splitting, is preparing yourself.

    Karen: In other words, everyone needs to read Splitting.

    Bill: This is the book that gives you the psychological and the legal big picture. And yeah, we've sold over 100,000 copies of this. It's so relevant to what people are going through. And I'm sad to say, the first edition came out in 2011, second edition came out in 2021, and the dynamics and problems are exactly the same. And I think it's the nature of putting family disputes in an adversarial system. It brings out the worst in people, and that's why try to settle if you can. And with high-conflict people, I'd say about half of high-conflict people cases do settle. So it's worth a try, but the other half, you end up in court.

    So here's the ways to prepare. First of all, talk to a lawyer, even if it's just a consultation. Find out what might happen here. Your spouse doesn't even know you're thinking of divorce yet. Get your information, because as soon as it becomes clear you're getting divorced, and maybe even thinking about it, all that adversarial stuff starts coming out. So, talk to a lawyer.

    I think get a therapist. You want someone that's gonna help you through this, that understands what you need, but also understands the personality of your partner, and can say, "Well, yeah, it does sound like he has narcissistic tendencies, in which case, he might react this way to what you're doing." So that they can help you. So it isn't just to help with grieving and healing the loss of the marriage, and the dream of the marriage. That's often what people are really grieving, because the real marriage didn't turn out to be like the dream. So, they're grieving the real one and the dream. So have a therapist.

    Another thing, and this is in the front of the book, is document. Write things down that are perhaps controversial incidents. Let's say that you're doing an exchange of the kids, and there's some papers that you need from the other person, and you get into an argument, or maybe there's the papers and you're pushing and pulling. I've had cases where there are people pushing and pulling, and then one person throws their head back, hits the wall, falls down, and then says it's a domestic violence case, when, in fact, it was a framed domestic violence case. Other cases are real domestic violence cases: "This was done, this was done, and then he did this, he grabbed me by the neck." And you want to write this down as accurately as you can, on the same day, if you can. Maybe it's that evening, because if you're in court someday, and you're saying, "What happened six months ago?" Well, you say, "Can I refresh my memory with my notes from that day?" Contemporaneous notes.

    So, you want to have that. You may have to submit a declaration. Suddenly you're in court, an ex parte hearing, emergency hearing, defending against something that was a really minor incident that's being called something bigger than it is. So, you want to document, keep track of that. Now, if you're still living in the same home, you may want to not necessarily keep that in your computer. You may want to put it on a thumb drive. Keep it safe somewhere. But keep some notes.

    Other things: the way you communicate with your spouse is very important, because that's going to become evidence. Those hostile emails and texts?

    Karen: Yes, they are.

    Bill: If email conversations end up in court, you want to have emails in the BIFF format: brief, informative, friendly, and firm. And you have one of the books.

    Karen: Got it right here.

    Bill: Yeah. So, what I should tell you is that's the original book, and we now have one specific for co-parents in divorce, because that's one of the biggest areas of high-conflict communication, with 28 examples of how not to do it, and then how to do it. So, if there's a dental appointment coming up, there's an issue with that, we have an example of that. Birthday parties, changing the schedule, all that stuff, signing kids up for soccer.

    So, brief, informative, friendly, and firm takes some practice, and I want to add kind of a footnote here. We've been teaching the BIFF method since 2007. In the last couple years, AI has come on the scene.

    Karen: I was just gonna ask you about that.

    Bill: And they scoop up books, and they trained themselves on books, and they included six of my books. Anthropic, I don't know about the others, but Anthropic picked up six of my books, including the BIFF book. And now, if you go on Claude, and actually ChatGPT, Copilot, any of those, and say, "Please write me a BIFF response to this hostile email," it will do it for you.

    But what I want to tell you is, it doesn't know you, it doesn't know your co-parent, and it doesn't know your situation. So you're getting kind of the average-of-the-universe response. And two problems with that. One is it may actually not be good for your situation because of that. Yours may have other aspects to it. But the other is it interferes with you learning how to do it yourself. Because the feedback we get is when people learn to write BIFF responses to a hostile ex, they also learn how to think differently about that person, and how to think more strategically and less defensively.

    And so, as you go through, there's ten questions we have to ask yourself. You go through those: Are those brief, informative, friendly, and firm? Is there any advice, admonishments, apologies? Because apologies feed the other person's belief that it's all your fault, so don't include them. How do you think the other person will respond? Changes you'll make. And do you need to get someone else's input on it? Which is often real helpful.

    So, you learn that process of asking those questions yourself, and you become more strategic and less defensive, even in your verbal conversations. And it actually improves relationships and improves confidence. But if you just turn it over to ChatGPT, "Write me a BIFF response," every day, you're having them do it for you. You don't learn, and it doesn't necessarily fit your situation.

    Karen: Well, what about, though, tying the two concepts together of what you're writing and using, can and will be used against you in court, right? So how much do you want the AI maybe to double-check what you're doing? Or not even just AI, even some of the co-parenting apps. I know OurFamilyWizard, which is a great co-parenting app, has a ToneMeter, right, which will say to you, "Do you really want to say it that way? That's a little in the red zone. Let's try this." Is that helpful?

    Bill: It is helpful. And we have a good relationship with OFW, OurFamilyWizard, because we teach people how to do it, so that the ToneMeter doesn't just say, "Not so good here." We teach people how to do it so that they're getting better and better. So, we teach the method, and that teaches if you're over the line a little bit. But OurFamilyWizard, a lot of the cases I consult on have court-ordered OurFamilyWizard conversations. And people show them to me, and I say, "Well, your responses could be a little more BIFF. You're still admonishing the other party." That's one of the most common mistakes people make, is "You should know better than to…" And that just escalates high-conflict people, and it looks nasty. Just be brief, informative, friendly, and firm.

    Karen: So, this is maybe not such an uplifting question here, but is there any hope? If you're married to a high-conflict person, and now you're divorcing a high-conflict person, and your divorce is miserable, and then afterwards, you continue to co-parent, and that experience is miserable for you, and it's miserable for the kids, is there any hope that your ex could change, or that things will get better, or you'll get to some kind of peace?

    Bill: Yes, yes, there is hope. First of all, the biggest thing is that the conflicts start to fade with time, especially if you practice being very consistent at setting boundaries, setting limits, what you'll engage with. BIFF responses are one way of disengaging from conflict. Seeing each other less, having exchanges at school, things like that, so that there's less and less interactions. And over time, what we see is high-conflict people in many ways get distracted in their lives into new relationships, new work issues, etc. However, they'll reappear from time to time in a crisis mode. And you just have to stick with your not engaging, not arguing about the past, trying to give them insight into themselves, not getting too emotional, all that stuff. And then they tend to subside, and you start having more and more space in between those kinds of eruptions.

    Yeah, and this is something I generally say to people dealing with a high-conflict co-parent: if your case isn't going well, fight hard, like the three themes and all of that, for two years. And the best you get after two years is probably the place to settle in and accept, because you don't want to spend 18 years fighting in family court, especially over the kids. Family court's not a good place for raising children, and judges will be the first to tell you that.

    But over time, and let's take narcissists, for example, because people talk a lot about narcissists today, narcissists really like attention. So when there's court hearings coming up is when they're most active, most intense, most perfect. In other words, suddenly they're doing all the parenting stuff just right, all of that. After the spotlight is off… I've had many cases like this, where, let's say, a high-conflict husband, now ex-husband, fights hard for 50-50 custody, and then has their new girlfriend or their mother do most of the parenting. And it's like, "I got the trophy, and it's on the shelf. I've got custody."

    And let me quickly tell you a funny example. I had a client, the mom, 15-year-old boy. Mom says, "I want to get divorced." Dad's upset. He starts suddenly spending time with the son, and he tells the son, "You know your mom's too controlling. Your mom does all these things." And the boy comes back after a weekend with Dad and says, "Mom, you know you're too controlling, and you're too this, and you're too that." And then it's time to get a parenting plan, and the boy says, "I want to live with Dad." And Dad, of course, has told the boy, "You want to live with me, right?" Took him on fishing trips, gave him a really nice cell phone at 15, all that stuff.

    Well, my client said, "I'm very secure with my relationship with my son, so if he wants to go live with his dad for a while, that's fine with me." And so they go to Family Court Services in California. It's a mediation of parenting. And the mediator says, "Well, the boy's relationship with the mom is distressed, so I recommend it goes with the dad." So that all happens. She doesn't fight it.

    And then it was about a month later, Dad took a job. I'm in San Diego. He took a job in LA, which is two hours' drive away, four hours during rush hour. And so he took a job supervising construction, where he'd go up on Monday and he'd come back on Friday. And he stayed up there, and this is a true story. He fought for custody, but then he had a job that was his priority.

    So the boy comes back on his second weekend with Mom, says, "Mom, I got an idea. How about I live with you, but you let Dad have custody?" And so my client calls me up, says, "Can we do that? Can we just leave the custody orders that he lives with Dad, but he actually lives with me?" And I said, "If Dad doesn't rock the boat, sure." And that's what they did. It was this 15-year-old's idea: "I get to live with Mom, and Dad gets to have the trophy of custody on the shelf."

    Karen: But the challenge with that, as you know as a lawyer, is that if Dad gets a bee in his bonnet about who knows what, he can pull the rug out from underneath Mom and the kid and say, "No, the paper says you live with me."

    Bill: No, absolutely. And the reality was that happened for about a year, and then it officially went back to her. But he had a year: "I had custody for a year of my son. I'm a good dad." And it's like, you can be a good dad without having to have custody. It worked in that case, but yeah, I don't recommend that, because it's an unstable solution, as you said. Dad could easily say, "Whoa, whoa…" But we had enough evidence, we probably would have switched custody back anyway if he made a fight about it.

    Karen: Yeah, that's interesting. I want to be respectful of your time, and before I let you go, I just need to ask you about a relatively recent concept that's been floating around in the laws, and things have been changing: the concept of coercive control. How does that fit into this whole high-conflict landscape and all the different personality disorders?

    Bill: Yeah, so coercive control is a very common characteristic of high-conflict personalities. So let me say the legal term, because in 2021, California adopted that as a basis for getting restraining orders in family law cases, even without violence. It's most commonly associated with domestic violence. They call it coercive controlling violence, where you may have broken bones and bruises, and that's the worst form of domestic violence, is coercive controlling violence.

    But the coercive control may include controlling finances, hiding money, controlling healthcare: "Don't go to the doctor for that bruise, it's gonna go away in a couple days," because they caused the bruise. Coercive control against spending time with family and friends, isolating people. So it's part of the high-conflict personality pattern.

    There's some research on personality disorders that says that Cluster B personality disorders, which is borderline, narcissist, antisocial, histrionic, have strong associations with domineeringness, vindictiveness, and intrusiveness. And these go with coercive control, so these are like umbrella terms for patterns of behavior. So high-conflict people tend to have coercive control because they want to dominate other people, they get vindictive if they don't get what they want, and they often are intrusive, which means they lack emotional boundaries with children, and also with their partners: "Where did you just go? Who did you just talk to?" All of that kind of intrusiveness.

    So I would say coercive control is a common pattern of high-conflict people, and one type of violence with coercive control is the worst, because people really get isolated, live in a state of fear. There's other domestic violence, pushing and shoving, they call it situational couple violence, that isn't coercive control, generally isn't broken bones and bruises, and is a lack of conflict resolution skills. And that's something that people can learn, and separating often stops that. So that's the difference. Coercive control, one person tries to control the other. High-conflict people do that a lot, and a lot of domestic violence perpetrators do that.

    Karen: How do you know if you're in a situation where there is some form of coercive control? How do you know if it's situational, as you just said, or whether it rises to a different level, whether it is that pattern? Because I would assume the way you handle it is different. Do you need more conflict resolution skills, or is that just not gonna help?

    Bill: Yeah, I think there's two things. One is, do you carry an ongoing sense of fear and dread? In other words, do you fear this person's gonna come around and try to tell me what to do, and control, take my phone away, keep me from leaving the house? All of those are good examples.

    Actually, I might mention, I stopped doing it, but I have a blog on Psychology Today that I did for… what was it? About eight years. Got about 100 blogs, and one of them is "Is Coercive Control Part of Your Relationship?" And I have a list there from the California law of what coercive control is, so there's a lot of things to look at. But it's, do you feel controlled by the other person? Rather than situational couple violence, which is, are you angry at the other person because of what they did, and you're not afraid of them? In other words, ongoing fear usually isn't part of situational couple violence. People push, slap, they're too aggressive, and couples with that can learn. You go to anger management class or something, and you learn to redirect those impulses and how to use words instead of slaps.

    But coercive control, basically, people know it. They have fear and dread, and they change their lives, they change their routines because of that. They're afraid: "I'm not going to see my sister this weekend, because that'll upset my husband too much. But I really would like to see her, but I don't want to upset him." That's coercive control.

    Karen: So, if somebody is in that situation, and they know it, whether they can put words to it or not, they have that sense of fear and dread, and they want to get out of the situation, and they want a divorce, are there certain things that they should or shouldn't do to prepare and to actually get out of the situation safely?

    Bill: Yes, yes, because this can be the most dangerous time with an abusive partner. And I'd say 85% of coercive controlling partners are men, maybe 15% are women. I've dealt with some men. It's the same pattern, just reversed.

    But here's what I recommend, and what I've done as a lawyer, and you may have done this too, I don't know, is you don't announce, "I want to get divorced from you," and then walk out the door. You get to a safe place, you've made an arrangement with a lawyer for having papers served, and usually you want to have the kids either with you or some other safe place. And then either you make a phone call and tell your spouse, "I want to get a divorce," and such, or someone serves them with papers that says, "Your wife wants to get divorced, here you go, and there's gonna be a court hearing in two weeks," and this and that. Hopefully, there's a letter that says, "Your wife wants to settle this amicably, and recommends that you get a lawyer, and that the lawyers talk, and here's the wife's lawyer's name, and maybe go to mediation, but we want to try to resolve this out of court, and this is just an awkward time, and we understand that." So a good cover letter from the lawyer that comes with serving the papers is what I've found helpful.

    And so, when that's played out, usually the husband is the one getting served. He goes through his outrage without her right there, talks to friends, and it's like, "Well, she'll pay for this, and she'll never see the kids again. I'm going to court, I'm gonna win, I'm gonna tell the judge all the terrible things she did." But she also has a list of terrible things that have happened to her. And so, I think that's the approach: be well prepared and in a safe place when the message is delivered.

    Karen: Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. Bill, honestly, I could continue the conversation for hours and hours, but I want to respect your time. I thank you so much for being here. Can you tell the audience a little bit about where they can find you if they want to learn more, and more importantly, where they can find all of your books, not just BIFF, but all four, five, however many books you have?

    Bill: Yeah, so the best place is highconflictinstitute.com. It's www.highconflictinstitute.com. We've got all the books there, but you can also get them on Amazon, at Barnes & Noble, at independent bookstores. I mentioned two of the books. If you get the BIFF book, BIFF for CoParent Communication has a green cover.

    We also have a book out last year called SLIC Solutions. S-L-I-C stands for Setting Limits and Imposing Consequences. It's helpful for setting limits in a divorce, deciding when you need to go back to court or not. There's a domestic violence case, there's an alienation case, as well as it includes neighbors and workplace and other settings. So, SLIC Solutions.

    There's a new book that's coming out next week. It's the second edition of So, What's Your Proposal? And it starts out with a divorce mediation and how it can go with making a proposal, asking questions, and then saying yes, no, or I'll think about it. It's a structured process to help negotiate issues in a divorce or any setting. There's school examples, workplace, all of that. And it's four letters, because everything we do, we narrow it down to four letters, so it's SWYP, S-W-Y-P, and that stands for "So, What's Your Proposal?" And here you go. So, What's Your Proposal? And it's "turn conflicts into agreements in three simple steps."

    Karen: I love that. I am going to have to go get that. And for everyone who's listening or watching, all of Bill's books will be hyperlinked in the show notes, so it'll be very, very easy to find. And I have to say, Bill, one of the things that I really enjoy about your books is that there's a lot of stories in them. So it's not just these abstract concepts that put people to sleep. The stories are interesting, and you can use them to say, "Oh yeah, this applies to me," and "Oh yeah, this situation, that's really not me," right?

    Bill: Yeah, and many of the stories are true stories. Some of them are based on true stories, but slightly different. But yeah, that's what we find is the best way, is to give people an example. And I want to give people hope. We'll kind of end with hope, because if you learn skills like this, it does tend to influence the other person. They even start writing back with the BIFF format if you use it long enough, because they realize that's gonna look better in court. So, use these skills. You'll have more confidence, you'll feel better about yourself, and you'll manage your relationship with your ex better, and help your kids. So, all put together, this has been a lot of what our work with High Conflict Institute is, but it can be used by anybody. And I'll say also thank you so much, Karen, for letting me talk on and on about this stuff.

    Karen: Oh, no, I am so appreciative, and I know the audience will be too. It seems like, when you're a divorce professional, that everybody is going through a high-conflict divorce, because those are the ones that take all your time and attention. Percentage-wise, it might not be most of the people, but when you're in it, you're really in it, and people need this. They need your work so desperately. It's really made a huge difference. So, thank you so much for the work that you do. Thank you for being on the show and sharing everything that you shared.

    Bill: Thank you for the chance.

    Karen: And for those of you who are out there watching or listening, if you've enjoyed today's conversation, I encourage you, like this episode, subscribe to the podcast, subscribe to the YouTube channel, and I look forward to talking with you again next time.

    Head shot of Karen Covy in an Orange jacket smiling at the camera with her hand on her chin.

    Karen Covy is a Divorce Coach, Lawyer, Mediator, Author, and Speaker. She coaches high net worth professionals and successful business owners to make hard decisions about their marriage with confidence, and to navigate divorce with dignity.  She speaks and writes about decision-making, divorce, and living life on your terms. To connect with Karen and discover how she can help you, CLICK HERE.


    Tags

    coercive control, dealing with divorce, divorcing a narcissist, high conflict divorce, life after divorce, off the fence podcast


    You may also like

    Comments are welcome and monitored. The site owner reserves the right (in her sole discretion) NOT to publish any comment she deems to be disparaging, demeaning, rude, or offensive.

    {"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}
    >